{
  "id": 61,
  "slug": "brief-10-venues",
  "kind": "research",
  "name": "brief-10-venues",
  "summary": null,
  "body_md": null,
  "lines": [
    "# brief-10-venues — BIP venue map + reader evidence (2026)",
    "**Brief:** 10 · **Angle:** a (venues + readers) · **Depth:** deep · **Written:** 2026-09-06 Asia/Tbilisi  ",
    "**Question:** Is there a real build-in-public *space* with an actual public (not only posters into the void)?  ",
    "**Method:** live page fetches + secondary traffic/stats; URL per claim; mark single-source; conflict called out.",
    "---",
    "## 1. Executive map (alive vs dead vs not-a-venue)",
    "| Venue | URL | What it is | Who runs it | Founded / key date | Size signal (2025–26) | Growing / quiet / dead | Price | Reader evidence |",
    "|------|-----|------------|-------------|--------------------|------------------------|------------------------|-------|-----------------|",
    "| X / #buildinpublic | https://x.com/search?q=%23buildinpublic | Hashtag + informal graph; optional X Community ~10.8K cited | Platform (X) | BIP culture ~2019+ | Still default primary BIP channel 2026 | Alive, attention-skewed to winners | Free (+ API cost) | Levels: **1B views / 12 mo** on one account (primary). Median: void posts common (secondary) |",
    "| Indie Hackers | https://www.indiehackers.com/ | Forum + interviews + newsletter | Courtland/Channing Allen (bought back from Stripe Apr 2023) | 2016; Stripe 2017; indie again 2023 | Semrush **1.12M visits Jul 2026**, avg session **08:22**, +17.44% MoM; May 777K → Jun 950K → Jul 1.12M | Stabilized / quieter than Stripe-era forum buzz; traffic up | Free + IH Plus | Audience = builders/peers not buyers (practitioner guides). Traffic ≠ reply density |",
    "| WIP.co | https://wip.co/ · https://wip.co/join | Paid accountability feed (daily todos / streaks) | Marc Köhlbrugge et al. | ~2010s maker streak product lineage | Landing claims **3,765 makers** (live fetch 2026-09-06) | Alive — home feed updating minutes apart on 2026-09-04 | **$199/yr** or **$29/mo** | Sample intro post: **5 replies**, peer welcomes (makers→makers). Designed as shippers, not lurker buyers |",
    "| buildinpublic.so | https://www.buildinpublic.so/ | SaaS: commits → posts (\"Loudy\", Dev Cards) | Product co. (Loudy brand) | Active 2026 blog May 19 2026 | Pricing live $9 / $19 / $49 mo | Alive as **tool**, not town square | Trial + paid | Their own blog names \"shipping into the void\" as most-cited BIP pain — evidence the default is low engagement |",
    "| r/SideProject | https://www.reddit.com/r/SideProject/ | Subreddit launch/feedback | Reddit mods | Long-running | Trackers conflict: RedditGrow **478K+**; ReddTrends **828.8K** (+6.8K/7d) [2026] | Growing (per ReddTrends) | Free | Launch/feedback culture; engagement = other builders. Box Reddit API blocked this run — sizes secondary |",
    "| r/buildinpublic | https://www.reddit.com/r/buildinpublic/ | Journey / metrics updates | Reddit mods | Newer niche | Trackers conflict hard: RedditGrow/SaaSCity **~30–32K**; GummySearch **115k** (updated 2026-09-04) | Unclear (data conflict) | Free | Self-promo heavy themes (GummySearch). Treat as small–mid BIP sub; verify live before decisions |",
    "| r/indiehackers | https://www.reddit.com/r/indiehackers/ | IH-adjacent Reddit | Reddit mods | — | c93n / vibe guides ~**100–117K** (2025–26 secondary) | Active | Free | Peer authenticity valued; AI spam frowned (community norms) |",
    "| Hacker News Show HN | https://news.ycombinator.com/show | Episodic launch surface | YC / HN | Ongoing | Hits vary 0–hundreds comments | Alive (episodic) | Free | Real strangers read when front-paged; not a standing BIP club |",
    "| Product Hunt | https://www.producthunt.com/ | Launch day + maker profiles | PH | Ongoing | Still launch theater; BIP.so 2026 guide: no longer default first channel | Alive, less \"first launch\" default | Free | Burst readers on launch day; weak as daily BIP home |",
    "| Peerlist | https://peerlist.io/ | Builder professional network / scroll | Peerlist, Inc. | Active 2026 | Live show posts | Alive | Free (+?) | Sample Foundra show posts: **3–12 upvotes**, few comments — thin stranger read |",
    "| Bluesky #buildinpublic | https://bsky.app/profile/did:plc:oio4hkxaop4ao4wz2pp3f4cr/feed/build | Hashtag + custom feeds + starter packs | Community feeds | 2024–26 migration | Feeds liked by hundreds (not millions) | Growing niche secondary | Free | Gentler maker pace; smaller absolute public than X |",
    "| Threads / LinkedIn BIP | platform native | Professional BIP cross-post | Meta / LinkedIn | — | LI catching for B2B (BIP.so platforms guide May 2026) | Alive | Free | More buyer-adjacent on LI for B2B; still not a dedicated BIP town |",
    "| Small Bets | https://smallbets.co / Campfire | Paid course+community | Daniel Vassallo | 2021 | Hive Index ~**8K**; other guides **4K+** (conflict) | Alive, high signal | ~$400–500 one-time (guides) | Paid filter → members read workshops/chat; not open public |",
    "| Hampton | https://joinhampton.com (coverage) | Vetted founder peer groups | Sam Parr / Joe Speiser | Public Mar 2023 | **1,000+** members; ~**$8M ARR** (Community Inc. analysis) | Growing controlled | High (application) | Closed public — peers read peers; not open BIP |",
    "| MegaMaker | https://megamaker.co/ | Indie maker community | MegaMaker | Long-running | Landing **833 members** (live 2026-09-06) | Quiet/stable small | Paid (landing) | Small paid room |",
    "| Ramen Club (ex Indie Worldwide domain path) | https://ramenclub.com/ (indieworldwide.co resolves here) | Slack for bootstrapped SaaS | Ramen Club | — | **400+** founders (live meta) | Alive small | Paid | Closed Slack public |",
    "| Nomad List / Levels ecosystem | https://nomads.com / RemoteOK etc. | Products + X as media | Pieter Levels | 2014+ | X account as media co. | Alive | Product $ | Readers exist at scale on X around Levels; ecosystem ≠ BIP venue for newcomers |",
    "| Polywork | was polywork.com | Professional activity network | Peter Johnston | Shut **2025-01-31** | Dead | **Dead** | — | Autopsy: could not find path to scale; capital returned (ShowProof guide) |",
    "| Buildspace | https://buildspace.so/letter | Cohort / Discord / IRL | Farza Majeed | Shut **2024-08-23** | Peak: 125K cumulative participants; Discord ~8.6K (2023 secondary) | **Dead** | — | Autopsy in founders' words: passion/\"done\", out of ideas; not runway (letter) |",
    "| Makerlog | getmakerlog.com → ambitiousfounder.com | Was streak maker social | Sergio Mattei → acquired 2022 Josh Manders | 2018; acquired 2022 | Domain redirect 2026; LinkedIn \"Makerlog\" ~219 visits | **Effectively dead as BIP venue** | — | Streak model absorbed/redirected; not a live BIP square |",
    "| Foundra (as BIP venue) | foundra.ai / Peerlist project | **Not a BIP venue** — AI planning tool | Spencer Claydon | 2026 | Peerlist rank snapshots | N/A | Tool $ | Misnamed in brief list: not a public BIP space |",
    "| codevibing | https://codevibing.com/ | Agent-assisted BIP for Claude Code | Derek Lomas et al. | 2026 | Live: **31 builders** | Embryonic | Free | Agent-native posting with human approve — tiny real space |",
    "---",
    "## 2. Top-5 venues — who actually READS",
    "### 1) X (#buildinpublic / indie graph)",
    "- **Reader proof (primary):** Pieter Levels — \"I got 1 billion views on X in the last 12 months\" ≈ **2.74M views/day**; post itself shows large reply count on original X (blog mirror: https://levels.io/1-billion-views-on-x-in-12-months).",
    "- **Skew:** Reach concentrates on accounts that already compound. Secondary guides (BIP.so void post; Averi; Futurion 2026) say median founders get founder-peer engagement, not buyers.",
    "- **Audience mix:** Other builders + some operators/buyers when product is founder-facing; otherwise peer theater.",
    "- **Verdict:** Real public exists **at the head**; **void is default at the tail**.",
    "### 2) Indie Hackers",
    "- **Reader proof (primary traffic):** Semrush Jul 2026 **1.12M visits**, session **08:22**, mostly Direct 51.9% + Google 33.6% — people open the site (https://www.semrush.com/website/indiehackers.com/overview/).",
    "- **Caveat:** Semrush keyword table on same page looks polluted (unrelated head terms); use visits/session, not keyword ranks.",
    "- **Engagement character (secondary):** Nilkick / practitioner guides — \"handful of thoughtful replies\", community of builders not buyers; quieter than Stripe-era forum peak (https://nilkick.com/resources/introducing-your-product-on-indie-hackers).",
    "- **Audience mix:** Peer founders / aspiring indie hackers.",
    "- **Verdict:** Real *readers* (traffic), thin *stranger commercial* public.",
    "### 3) WIP.co",
    "- **Size (primary):** 3,765 makers; paid $199/yr (https://wip.co/join).",
    "- **Reader proof:** Live feed is continuous todos (https://wip.co/). Sample public intro: **5 replies** from other makers (https://wip.co/posts/joined-today-so-sharing-my-what-i-ve-been-building-bkqu9a).",
    "- **Audience mix:** Almost entirely other shippers (by design: \"not lurkers\").",
    "- **Verdict:** Real small public of **posters who also read** — accountability circle, not customer audience.",
    "### 4) r/SideProject",
    "- **Size (secondary, conflict):** 478K–829K members depending on tracker (https://redditgrow.ai/best-subreddits/side-projects · https://www.reddtrends.com/r/sideproject).",
    "- **Reader proof:** Launch posts routinely get feedback comments (community expectation); exact replies/views need live Reddit (API blocked this run).",
    "- **Audience mix:** Builders sharing projects — high poster/reader overlap.",
    "- **Verdict:** Large *member* base; engagement is peer. Treat as distribution for feedback, not buyers.",
    "### 5) Paid rooms (Small Bets / Hampton / MegaMaker / Ramen)",
    "- **Sizes:** Small Bets 4–8K (conflict); Hampton 1K+; MegaMaker **833** (primary landing); Ramen **400+** (primary).",
    "- **Reader proof:** Paid membership implies intentional reading/chat; not measurable as open MAU here.",
    "- **Audience mix:** Peer founders at similar stage.",
    "- **Verdict:** Highest signal **private** publics; fail \"open public\" test.",
    "---",
    "## 3. Poster vs reader ratio (synthesis of evidence)",
    "| Claim | Evidence | Confidence |",
    "|-------|----------|------------|",
    "| A real reading public exists for BIP *celebrities* on X | Levels 1B views primary | High |",
    "| Median BIP post lands in low engagement / \"void\" | BIP.so \"Shipping Into the Void\" documents pain as universal; calibrates weeks 1–2 at 5–30 likes from zero (https://www.buildinpublic.so/blog/shipping-into-the-void) | Med–High (vendor blog, but cites IH/Wisp patterns) |",
    "| Dedicated BIP venues are mostly other posters | WIP design + IH guides + Reddit BIP norms | High |",
    "| Open web lacks one \"BIP town square\" with loyal non-builder readers | Dead Polywork/Buildspace/Makerlog; tools (buildinpublic.so) replace places | High |",
    "**Counts this doc:** venues tabulated **22** · primary live fetches **≥8** · secondary trackers **≥6** · dead/autopsy **3** · misclassified-as-venue **1** (Foundra).",
    "---",
    "## 4. Missing / partial",
    "- Live Reddit subscriber + active counts (API blocked).",
    "- Exact #buildinpublic daily post/reply rates on X (needs X API credits; paused per lock).",
    "- IH newsletter current subscriber count (older ~85K cited historically; not reconfirmed 2026).",
    "- Discord Launch House / IH Discord live member counts.",
    "**Next hop if extended:** X search_posts metrics for #buildinpublic sample; old.reddit HTML scrape; Small Bets pricing page primary."
  ],
  "author": "weebo",
  "sources": null,
  "related": null,
  "verified_at": null,
  "updated_at": "2026-09-06T14:13:41.798Z",
  "cover_url": null
}